1. #1
    Unregistered

    Is it legal for doctors to go on strike?

    Doctors like police and Army come under the essential services and therefore is it legal for doctors to go on strike? The Army and police cannot go on strike then how come doctors can go on strike and no action is taken against them?

  2. #2
    Srishti Array
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    388

    Re: Is it legal for doctors to go on strike?

    hello,
    no , you can not go on strikes, you are associated with services of public. how can you ask this. sorry for being rude. but doctors can not go on strike.
    Good luck

  3. #3
    manojbadoniya Array
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    802

    Re: Is it legal for doctors to go on strike?

    Dear you have asked a very good question which comes in the mind of everybody in the world and it is really illegal according to the law and regulations of the hospital and health care centers because if the doctors would go on strike then what would happen for the patients in the hospital and any other where and it is the responsibility of these following positions that they should never go on strike and if they go then what may happen in the world

    1. Doctors : Doctors are really like god because in the golden period they may save the life of the person and it is their responsibility and they should also understand that if they would go on strike then what may happen with those who are fighting with the life and death and if they would stay on their way then so many patients may loose their life which is gifted by the GOD so that the doctors should be responsible about this

    2. Police : Police is the most responsible to the happiness of the peoples and Police cares about everything that's why they never go for holidays and when the public holidays comes, they always perform their duty in the country and serve the peoples from their rights and you may take the example of - Sunday, Festivals and other occasions, summits, meeting, debates, sports etc. they always decided for the duty at that time and when somebody gets problems then they may leave the home in the night so they also are not able to go on strike

    3. Indian Army/Military : Indian army has huge rights but only when the home minister of the country allow them to use and if they go on strike then the another country army may invade at our country that's why the government did not provide them the authority to go on strike as POLICE

    4. Teacher/Professor : Dear both Doctor and Teacher considered as the GOD because they may save the life and they may destroy the life of the person and the teacher is more responsible for the future of the students because if they would teach wrong or would not teach then the students may go there where they want and the way may not be really good so that the teachers also should be responsible for their duty and should not go on strike

    Dear the Police and Army has no authority to go on strike but the doctors and teachers sometimes go on strike and there is nothing about the teachers strike but the doctors should never do it because they are responsible to save a life and due to the unavailability of the medical assistance, patient may loose his/her life but dear the doctors also does not go for strike themselves, it is because the government, government hires doctors on ad hoc and during the ad hoc period the doctors gets less salary of their work so that they go on strike and sometimes because of something else they go on that so that the government should understand their problems that why they are on strike and provide them the complete solution and whatever they want

    All the best

  4. #4
    john215 Array
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    796

    Re: Is it legal for doctors to go on strike?

    Re: It is legal for doctors to go on strike?

    Dear friend,

    Strike against what?????

    Most of use are in Private Practice.
    The who are not have brokered their own contracts...........

    Who would we strike against????

    16 Years as a physician

    so you can not go on strikes
    But doctors can not go on strike.

    good luck......................


  5. #5
    Ashok Array
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Posts
    2,293

    Re: Is it legal for doctors to go on strike?

    Quote Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
    Doctors like police and Army come under the essential services and therefore is it legal for doctors to go on strike? The Army and police cannot go on strike then how come doctors can go on strike and no action is taken against them?
    Dear Aspirant,

    Of course,the doctors should not go on strike,because they come under essential service.But they often go to meet their demand & they get it,that is why they prefer to go on strike.The govt.can not take action against the mass of the doctors,because they are the life saver of the people & all the juniors & seniors sometimes jointly involve in the strike.There are certain procedures to appoint them & it may not be possible for the doctor to appoint the senior most doctor.Secondly the doctors have always option for private practice,there by they can earn a lot.So the govt.is dependent upon the doctors & not the doctors are dependent upon the govt. to such an extent.

    So,the doctors go on strike & meet their demand.

    Thanks.

    Ashok..

  6. #6
    ajaymadhu Array
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    60

    Re: Is it legal for doctors to go on strike?

    Hi friend

    1) If the doctors like police and army, are enlisted under essential services , as you say , then they are certainly not allowed to go on strike. they are forbidden to go on strike as this will affect the health of the patients and also may prove dangerous to their lives.
    2) So certainly if doctors go on strike it is highly illegal and they can even be punished for that.
    3) Doctors should be responsible and not do such a thing. They cannot sacrifice the health and well being of their patients at any cost.

    4) If they have any problem they should try to solve it amicably with them and not resort to such things.

    I hope you understand. Good luck

  7. #7
    abhijeet2015 Array
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    334

    Re: Is it legal for doctors to go on strike?

    Hi..............,

    Generally doctors need to be maintained in a hospital for service.
    But in our country doctors first think about them self then about patient.
    You have never here that doctors of Private hospitals had gone to strike.
    This is just in case of government hospitals where government take no action.

    Thanks

  8. #8
    pushp Array
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Location
    bhopal
    Posts
    277

    Re: Is it legal for doctors to go on strike?

    Hello there !!!

    this seems to be the political topic dear.
    and this forum is made to serve your problem related to the technical field.
    so we are bound to give any compliment regarding this.
    as it can hurt any class of the people.

    so, it is better to keep this topics out of the EALP.
    this is the government topic to deal upon.

    hope i am clear to you.
    thanks for posting in EALP.
    pushp ranjan singh

  9. #9
    Boss Array
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Posts
    1,649

    Re: Is it legal for doctors to go on strike?

    Of course,the doctors mustn't maintain strike,because they are available below essential service.But they typically move to meet their demand & They savvy,that is why they like to travel on strike.The govt.can not take action against the mass of the doctors,Because they're the life saver of the folks & all the juniors & seniors generally put together involve within the strike.

    There are sure procedures to appoint them & it's going to not be potential for the doctor to appoint the senior most doctor.Secondly the doctors have perpetually choice for personal follow,there by they will earn lots.So the govt.is dependent upon the doctors & not the doctors ar dependent upon the government. to such associate degree extent.

    So,the doctors maintain strike & meet their demand.

    Dear you have got asked a sensible question that comes within the mind of everyone within the world and it's really felonious in step with the law and laws of the hospital and health care centers as a result of if the doctors would maintain strike then what would happen for the patients within the hospital and the other wherever and it's the responsibility of those following positions that they must ne'er maintain strike and if they're going then what could happen within the world

    Doctors : Doctors ar like god as a result of within the golden amount save the lifetime of the person and it's their responsibility and that they ought to additionally perceive that if they might maintain strike then what could happen with people who ar fighting with the life and death and if they might stay their method then such a big amount of patients may loose their life that is presented by the GOD in order that the doctors ought to be accountable concerning this

    Police : Police is that the most accountable to the happiness of the peoples and Police cares concerning everything that is why they ne'er select holidays and once the general public holidays comes, they perpetually perform their duty within the country and serve the peoples from their rights and you'll take the instance of - Sunday, Festivals and alternative occasions, summits, meeting, debates, sports etc. they perpetually set for the duty at that point and once someone gets issues then they will leave the house within the night in order that they are ineffectual to travel on strike

    Indian Army/Military : Indian army has large rights however only if the house minister of the country permit them to use and if they're going on strike then the another country army could invade at our country that is why the govt. failed to offer them the authority to travel on strike as POLICE

    Teacher/Professor : expensive each Doctor and Teacher thought of because the GOD as a result of save the life and that they could destroy the lifetime of the person teacher is well-versed for the longer term of the scholars as a result of if they might teach wrong or wouldn't teach then the scholars may go there wherever they require and therefore the method might not be particular in order that the lecturers also ought to be answerable for their duty and will not maintain strike

    Expensive the Police and military has no authority to travel on strike however the doctors and lecturers generally maintain strike and there's nothing concerning the lecturers strike however the doctors ought to ne'er get laid as a result of they're accountable to avoid wasting a life and thanks to the inconvenience of the medical help, patient could loose his/her life however expensive the doctors additionally doesn't select strike themselves, it's as a result of the govt., government hires doctors on accidental and through the accidental amount the doctors gets less pay of their work in order that they're going on strike and generally due to one thing else they're going thereon in order that the govt. ought to perceive their issues that why they're on strike and supply them the whole answer and no matter they require

+ Reply to Thread

Similar Threads

  1. Do homeopathic doctors come under criminal negligence act?
    By Unregistered in forum Professional Discussions
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 04-02-2013, 11:28 PM
  2. Are unani doctors eligible for doing surgery in Rajasthan?
    By Unregistered in forum Professional Discussions
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 19-01-2013, 01:43 PM
  3. Replies: 3
    Last Post: 17-12-2012, 07:00 PM
  4. Replies: 3
    Last Post: 11-11-2012, 09:56 PM
  5. Senior doctors are not punctual & leave the outdoor on resident doctors
    By Unregistered in forum Professional Discussions
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 31-10-2012, 02:17 PM